Oh Baby: Former Annie’s CEO Brings Good Food To The Small Set At Once Upon A Farm

By Bob Benenson, FamilyFarmed

During his more than a decade and a half leading Annie’s Inc., John Foraker played a pioneering role in creating the market sector for organic versions of popular consumer packaged goods (CPGs) such as macaroni-and-cheese mix, crackers and breakfast cereals. Foraker was so successful building the Annie’s Homegrown product line that General Mills bought the company in 2014 for $820 million.

So what is Foraker doing for an encore? He, with other innovators who include actress Jennifer Garner, has co-founded Once Upon A Farm, which is spearheading an effort to create a new retail category for fresh, organic, refrigerated baby food.

Foraker will discuss these experiences in Chicago on June 19, at FamilyFarmed’s Good Food Financing & Innovation Conference, where he will first present the keynote address, then join Carlotta Mast — New Hope Network’s senior vice president for content and insights — in a Fireside Chat. [For more information about the Conference, and to buy tickets, visit www.goodfoodfinancing.org.]


John Foraker, a pioneer in the organic packaged food sector, will share his experiences in a keynote speech and Fireside Chat at FamilyFarmed’s Good Food Financing & Innovation Conference in Chicago June 19. Foraker led Annie’s Homegrown to spectacular success before selling the company to General Mills for $820 million, and now is working with partners — including actress Jennifer Garner — to build a new market sector with Once Upon A Farm organic, fresh baby food.

In an interview with FamilyFarmed, Foraker related that the idea for Once Upon A Farm was developed by San Diego entrepreneurs Ari Raz and Cassandra Curtis in 2015. Foraker, after first investing money in the company, came on board last September as CEO.

“I had been looking at the fresh baby food space since I sold Annie’s, because I thought it was such a great opportunity to disrupt a pretty sleepy category. Baby food is a really big business, but there hadn’t been much innovation in it for about 10 years, when you had the advent of the pouch and organic,” Foraker explained.

He added that Once Upon A Farm’s strategy is predicated on the fast-rising interest in Good Food, particularly among younger adult consumers who are now raising families. “Most of the baby food that’s sitting on the shelves is older than the kids that are eating it,” Foraker said. “The trend toward fresh everywhere is really powerful.”

It was quite a different landscape 20 years ago when Foraker joined Annie’s, whose Annie’s Homegrown products (created by founder Annie Withey) had developed a regional following in New England since it launched in 1989. Whole Foods [Market] had maybe 30, 40 stores and they were just starting to buy up some of the big regional players like Bread and Circus. The natural-channel players were just really starting to get going. But we had a lot of difficulty selling Annie’s into a conventional grocery stores,” Foraker said.

Not that the idea of a fresh baby food category was a slam dunk when the Once Upon A Farm team started pitching late last year. “In the U.S. I think there’s about 300 stores maybe in September that had fresh baby food. And there’s 20,000 stores roughly that have fresh dog food,” Foraker said. But the company’s team had enormous assets in Foraker, with his track record of spectacular success at Annie’s, and Garner, a popular celebrity who serves as Once Upon A Farm’s chief brand officer.

Foraker said, “Jennifer Garner’s manager had been talking to them about doing something together, because she’d been wanting to get into healthy kids’ food for a long time. She has three kids, she spent the last decade working in the U.S. programs for Save The Children.” After meeting with Curtis and Raz, Foraker and Garner opted to join the company: “We share a common passion for healthy food and solving some of these social programs.”

Their combined star power paved the way for a big product rollout Foraker expects for late July in several major markets, including Chicago outlets of major retailers that include not only natural-channel markets such as Whole Foods, but also conventional chains such as Kroger, Mariano’s, Jewel Osco and Target (the last of which provided Annie’s with a crucial boost around a dozen years ago when it began stocking the company’s products).


The co-founders of the Once Upon A Farm organic, fresh baby food company are (from left) John Foraker, Jennifer Garner, Cassandra Curtis and Ari Raz. 

Betting Big On The Bunny

Foraker, at Annie’s, certainly rode the wave of accelerating consumer interest in organic and other sustainably produced CPGs. But a whole lot of marketing expertise went into Annie’s success as well. One of the company’s smartest ideas was Bernie the Bunny, featured on each Annie’s package as the company’s logo and in rabbit-shaped cheese crackers, cookies and fruit snacks.

“We had really good equity there with Bernie and the packaging,” Foraker said. “That brand was really about moms’ emotional connection to their kids. They wanted to do better and feed their kids better food for a small premium.”

Foraker said that when he took Annie’s Inc. public in 2012, it was not with the intention of attracting a Big Food buyer. “I took the company public to generate some liquidity,” Foraker said. “I felt like if we could remain independent longer we could continue the work that we were doing, build a bigger and stronger equity in a leading brand that would stand the test of time.”

But General Mills, though mainly a conventional CPG company, already had a history of buying and building organic brands such as Muir Glen canned tomato products and Cascadian Farm, which produces items such as cereals, granola bars and frozen produce. General Mills recognized Annie’s as a fit good enough to be worth buying for $820 million.

Foraker said he was comfortable with General Mills at the time of the sale, and he has subsequently been encouraged by the company’s deep dive into the developing concept of regenerative agriculture. General Mills recently purchased 34,000 acres of farmland in South Dakota, which is being transitioned through 2020 to grow organic wheat exclusively for Annie’s.

Annie's Homegrown


Annie's Homegrown

Annie’s Homegrown, now produced by General Mills, has plenty of shelf space at Whole Foods Market — one of the biggest national retailers cultivated by John Foraker during his successful tenure as company CEO. Popular products include Annie’s organic version of macaroni-and-cheese mix and rabbit-shaped crackers that play off the company’s mascot, Bernie the Bunny. Photos: Bob Benenson/FamilyFarmed

As Good Food — food produced as locally as possible using sustainable, humane and fair practices — increasingly erodes Big Food’s dominant market share, Big Food companies increasing are buying innovative upstart competitors. There are many Good Food activists who bridle at this phenomenon.

But Foraker believes that Annie’s advocacy of Good Food principles and General Mills’ show of sincerity in maintaining those have minimized any blowback over the sale. “No one was more vocal on GMO labeling or on the integrity of organic than myself and Annie’s,” Foraker said. “What was really great about General Mills was they didn’t dumb that down at all. They really supported what we stood for, they understood that our consumers wanted and expected that out of us. They really enabled it. I think Annie’s is a really great success story.”

The striving entrepreneurs attending FamilyFarmed’s Good Food Financing & Innovation Conference likely will be hanging on Foraker’s every word during his presentations. But as he goes back to square one in pushing a category-changing startup, Foraker says the best takeaways from his experience are what not to do.

“You know, I’ve been successful, but the flip side of that is, as any entrepreneur knows, I’ve also made a million mistakes,” Foraker said. “That’s the beauty of experience. You make mistakes early in your career and you learn from them.”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *